All comparisons / Scuba cylinders 20 HEAD-TO-HEAD COMPARISONS Scuba cylinders. Compare your options. Compare capacity, dimensions and buoyancy through the dive. Ratings apply to the named cylinder, not its valve, inspection condition or suitability for your gas plan. One scored model is not a comparative winner.
Different brands, real buying decisions. See our scores, the compromises, and which model gets our vote.
RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S80 90 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X S80 P3404V Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X S80 P3404V Scuba Cylinder 91 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: L6X S80 P3404V Scuba Cylinder
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S80 90 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X S80 P3405V Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X S80 P3405V Scuba Cylinder 90 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: S80
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S40Product photo coming soon
S40 89 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X S40 P3403V Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X S40 P3403V Scuba Cylinder 90 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: L6X S40 P3403V Scuba Cylinder
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S30 85 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X S40 P3403V Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X S40 P3403V Scuba Cylinder 90 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: L6X S40 P3403V Scuba Cylinder
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S45Product photo coming soon
S45 86 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X P3258V Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X P3258V Scuba Cylinder 88 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: L6X P3258V Scuba Cylinder
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S50Product photo coming soon
S50 87 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X P3258V Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X P3258V Scuba Cylinder 88 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: L6X P3258V Scuba Cylinder
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S13 82 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X A896/1/Y Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X A896/1/Y Scuba Cylinder 81 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: S13
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S50Product photo coming soon
S50 87 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X S80 P3404V Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X S80 P3404V Scuba Cylinder 91 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: L6X S80 P3404V Scuba Cylinder
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S45Product photo coming soon
S45 86 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X S40 P3403V Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X S40 P3403V Scuba Cylinder 90 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: L6X S40 P3403V Scuba Cylinder
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S80 90 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X P3258V Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X P3258V Scuba Cylinder 88 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: S80
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S40Product photo coming soon
S40 89 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X S80 P3405V Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X S80 P3405V Scuba Cylinder 90 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: L6X S80 P3405V Scuba Cylinder
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S30 85 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X A896/1/Y Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X A896/1/Y Scuba Cylinder 81 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: S30
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S13 82 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X S80 P3405V Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X S80 P3405V Scuba Cylinder 90 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: L6X S80 P3405V Scuba Cylinder
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S40Product photo coming soon
S40 89 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X S80 P3404V Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X S80 P3404V Scuba Cylinder 91 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: L6X S80 P3404V Scuba Cylinder
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S45Product photo coming soon
S45 86 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X A896/1/Y Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X A896/1/Y Scuba Cylinder 81 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: S45
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S30 85 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X P3258V Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X P3258V Scuba Cylinder 88 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: L6X P3258V Scuba Cylinder
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S50Product photo coming soon
S50 87 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X S40 P3403V Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X S40 P3403V Scuba Cylinder 90 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: L6X S40 P3403V Scuba Cylinder
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S13 82 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X S80 P3404V Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X S80 P3404V Scuba Cylinder 91 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: L6X S80 P3404V Scuba Cylinder
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S50Product photo coming soon
S50 87 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X S80 P3405V Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X S80 P3405V Scuba Cylinder 90 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: L6X S80 P3405V Scuba Cylinder
See the matchup → RED CORNER Catalina Cylinders S40Product photo coming soon
S40 89 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK VS BLUE CORNER Luxfer L6X A896/1/Y Scuba CylinderProduct photo coming soon
L6X A896/1/Y Scuba Cylinder 81 /100Our editorial score
OUR PICK Catalina Cylinders VS Luxfer Our pick: S40
See the matchup →